Thick vs Standard Gears with the Correct Carrier Break Guideline

When upgrading or re-gearing a vehicle’s differential, two critical concepts that often arise are Thick Ring Gears and Carrier Breaks. These terms are especially relevant in the context of aftermarket gear ratio changes for off-road, high-performance, and heavy-duty applications. Understanding the relationship between ring gear thickness and differential carrier compatibility is crucial for making informed decisions in drivetrain modifications.

What Are Thick Ring Gears?

Thick ring gears are modified versions of standard ring gears with increased thickness. They are primarily used to allow higher numerical gear ratios (e.g., 4.56, 4.88, 5.13) to be installed in vehicles originally equipped with lower numerical ratios (e.g., 3.55, 3.73) without replacing the carrier.

Why Are Thick Ring Gears Necessary?

Advantages of Thick Ring Gears

Allows reuse of the original carrier: This can save money and labor by avoiding the need for a new carrier when re-gearing.
Maintains factory differential compatibility: Ensures that aftermarket gears work with existing differentials.
Simplifies installation: Thick gears eliminate the need to change the carrier, reducing complexity.

Common Applications for Thick Ring Gears

Thick ring gears are commonly used in axle models such as:

Dana 30, 35, 44, 60, 80
GM 10-bolt, 12-bolt, 14-bolt
Ford 9″ differentials

Understanding Carrier Breaks

Image Source: https://www.crawlpedia.com/

Carrier breaks refer to the specific gear ratio ranges that require different carriers within the same axle model. Many differentials have a predefined gear ratio range that each carrier can support, meaning if you change to a ratio beyond a certain threshold, you must replace the carrier as well.

Carrier Breaks in Popular Axle Models

Different axle manufacturers define carrier breaks differently. Below are some common carrier break points:

Dana Axles

Dana 30: 3.73 and down (low carrier), 3.92 and up (high carrier)
Dana 44: 3.73 and down, 3.92 and up
Dana 60: 4.10 and down, 4.56 and up
Dana 80: 4.10 and down, 4.56 and up

GM Axles

GM 10-bolt (8.5″): 2.56 and down, 2.73 and up
GM 12-bolt truck (8.875″): 3.42 and down, 3.73 and up
GM 14-bolt full-float: 4.10 and down, 4.56 and up

Why Do Carrier Breaks Exist?

Carrier breaks are necessary due to the physical differences in ring gear mounting surfaces required for different gear ratios. When increasing the numerical gear ratio, the pinion gear shrinks in size, which shifts the ideal mounting location of the ring gear closer to the center of the carrier. Axle manufacturers design different carriers to accommodate this shift for optimal gear mesh and strength.

Thick Ring Gears vs. Carrier Replacement

When upgrading gear ratios, there are two main approaches:

Option 1: Use a Thick Ring Gear

Suitable when upgrading from a low-ratio carrier to a high-ratio gear without changing the carrier.
Allows higher numerical gear ratios to be used on a lower break carrier.
Cost-effective and easier to install than replacing the carrier.

Option 2: Replace the Carrier

Necessary when moving beyond the carrier break point.
Required if the new gear set is not available in a thick ring gear version.
Allows the use of a stronger or limited-slip/locking carrier upgrade (e.g., Detroit Locker, ARB Air Locker, or Eaton Truetrac).

Example

A Jeep Wrangler with a Dana 44 differential originally equipped with 3.73 gears wants to upgrade to 4.56. The stock carrier is a “low” break version (3.73 and down). The available options:

Use a thick 4.56 ring gear and retain the stock carrier.
Purchase a “high” carrier (3.92 and up) and a standard 4.56 ring gear.
Upgrade to a performance carrier like a limited-slip or selectable locker while also moving to the high break carrier.

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Thick Ring Gears & Carrier Replacement

When deciding whether to use a thick ring gear or replace the carrier, consider the following:

Budget Constraints

Thick ring gears are more affordable as they avoid the cost of a new carrier.
Carrier replacement can be expensive but may be required for extreme ratios or performance upgrades.

Installation Complexity

Thick ring gears simplify installation.
Carrier replacement requires a full differential setup, including backlash adjustment and potentially new shims and bearings.

Desired Performance Upgrade

If upgrading to a limited-slip or locking differential, replacing the carrier is necessary.
If only changing ratios, a thick ring gear is often the simplest solution.

Conclusion

Understanding thick ring gears and carrier breaks is essential for anyone modifying their vehicle’s drivetrain. Thick ring gears provide a cost-effective way to increase gear ratios without changing the carrier, while carrier breaks define when a new carrier is necessary for proper gear fitment. By carefully evaluating your differential type, budget, and performance needs, you can make the best decision for your specific re-gearing project.

Attention

Thick Ring Gears allow higher ratio gears to be used on a lower break carrier.
Carrier Breaks define the gear ratio ranges that require different carriers.
Choosing the right solution depends on budget, installation complexity, and desired performance upgrades.

Whether you’re an off-roader, racer, or just looking to optimize your vehicle’s gearing, making an informed decision on thick ring gears and carrier replacements ensures a successful upgrade. Always consult with an experienced differential specialist if unsure about compatibility and installation requirements.